Meet Our Team

Meet the people behind Nicklas Insurance Group.

Insurance advisors who truly work for you.

Home » About Our Agency » Meet Our Team

Not all insurance agents are created equal. At Nicklas Insurance Group, we go out of our way to treat our clients like people and we use our industry experience and diversified knowledge base to protect what you value most.

Get a Quote
Find team members by location.
St. Marys, PACoudersport, PAErie, PAClearfield, PAKnox, PAEbensburg, PAPittsburgh, PADuBois, PADonora, PA
St. Marys, PA

Nicklas Insurance Agency

John Mulcahy, RFC, CLU, CHFC, CPCU

John Mulcahy, RFC, CLU, CHFC, CPCU
Managing Principal

Randy Geci, CIC

Randy Geci, CIC
Account Executive

Mardi Means

Mardi Means
Account Executive

Collin Mulcahy

Collin Mulcahy
Accounting

Kristin Wileman

Kristin Wileman
Account Manager

Ashlyn Wileman

Ashlyn Wileman
Receptionist

Lisa Cooper

Lisa Cooper
Benefits Manager

Barb Adams

Barb Adams
Account Manager

Swift Kennedy & Co

Kurt Richards, CIC, CPIA

Kurt Richards, CIC, CPIA
Account Executive

Coudersport, PA

Coudersport Insuring

Carlene Hendershot

Carlene Hendershot
Account Manager

Erie, PA

Nicklas Insurance Agency

Elizabeth Edwards-Steen

Elizabeth Edwards-Steen
Account Executive

Maggie Meyer

Maggie Meyer
Account Manager

Amy Phillips

Amy Phillips
Account Manager

Clearfield, PA

Helmbold & Stewart Insurance

Dawn Shaw

Dawn Shaw
Operations Manager

Brian Reilly

Brian Reilly
Account Executive

Chris Ogorchock

Chris Ogorchock
Account Manager

Carol Ireland

Carol Ireland
Account Manager

Jeff Bellmore

Jeff Bellmore
Account Manager

Jo Ann McCracken

Jo Ann McCracken
Account Manager

Francine Shimchock

Francine Shimchock
Benefits Manager

Tori Rothrock

Tori Rothrock
Account Manager

Knox, PA

Beels Insurance

Bob Best

Bob Best
Account Executive

Deb Keister

Deb Keister
Account Manager

Rhonda Troup

Rhonda Troup
Account Manager

Samantha Carson

Samantha Carson
Account Manager

Karen Dittman
Customer Service Representative

Ebensburg, PA

Laurel Insurance Management/Swift Kennedy & Co.

Jay Markovich

Jay Markovich
Account Executive

Melinda Prasko

Melinda Prasko
Account Manager

Nicole Brawley

Nicole Brawley
Account Manager

Rose Schofield

Rose Schofield
Account Manager

Jane Bobik, CSR

Jane Bobik, CSR
Account Manager

Pam Holsinger

Pam Holsinger
Account Manager

Joe Hassen

Joe Hassen
Account Executive

Doris Shuss, CISR

Doris Shuss, CISR
Account Manager

Pittsburgh, PA

Pinnacle Group Insurance

Kirk Haldeman

Kirk Haldeman
Managing Principal

Mark Allston

Mark Allston
Account Executive

Pam Haldeman

Pam Haldeman
Account Manager

Lynn Marie

Lynn Marie
Account Manager

Garth Peebly

Garth Peebly
Account Executive

Michael Misour

Michael Misour
Account Executive

Rob Myers

Rob Myers
Account Executive

Stephanie Hyduk

Stephanie Hyduk
Account Manager

DuBois, PA

Swift Kennedy & Co.

George Heigel

George Heigel
Account Executive

Mike Nesbit

Mike Nesbit
Account Manager

Karen Dietz

Karen Dietz
Operations Manager

Jake Heigel

Jake Heigel
Account Executive

Sheri Fitzpatrick, CISR

Sheri Fitzpatrick, CISR
Account Manager

Linda Smith, CISR

Linda Smith, CISR
Account Manager

Ryan Carr

Ryan Carr
Account Manager

Jessica Coull

Jessica Coull
Account Manager

Sheela Hanzel

Sheela Hanzel
Account Manager

Brenda Morgan-Sedgwick

Brenda Morgan-Sedgwick
Account Manager

Donora, PA

Colgan Agency

Diane Folle

Diane Folle
Account Manager

Tammy Ulish

Tammy Ulish
Account Manager

Michelle Miller

Michelle Miller
Customer Service

About Our Agency - View of a Group of Diverse Coworkers Planning Business Strategy During a Meeting in the Office

Get Started Today

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

Get a Quote

  Request an Insurance Quote

As an independent agency, we are here to help you find the right coverage.

  • Please do not include sensitive, private information in this area.
  • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Get a Quote

It only takes a minute to get started.

  • Fill out the form, we’ll be in touch.
  • Go over your options with an agent.
  • Get the coverage you need.

Would you rather discuss this in person? Get in touch with an agent today!

Contact Us